One Punch Man is back in the spotlight, and this time it is not just about Saitama throwing another devastating punch. After Season 3 wrapped up with surprisingly strong ratings and commercial success, fans are already buzzing about what comes next. But there is a debate that refuses to die: should J.C. Staff return for Season 4, or is it time to hand the series to a different studio?
This is not a new conversation. J.C. Staff took over production from Madhouse starting with Season 2, and the transition sparked intense backlash from fans who remembered the fluid, explosive animation that Madhouse delivered in 2015. Season 3 managed to win people back with improved fight choreography and better pacing, but the question remains whether the studio can sustain that quality for another full season.
Why the Studio Debate Matters More Than Ever
One Punch Man is not your average anime. The series was created by ONE, who originally published the webcomic in 2009 before teaming up with illustrator Yusuke Murata for the manga remake that became a global phenomenon. The contrast between Saitama’s absurdly simple character design and the hyper-detailed backgrounds and villains has always been part of the show’s charm, and capturing that visual contrast requires serious animation skill.
Gege Akutami’s Jujutsu Kaisen and Koyoharu Gotouge’s Demon Slayer have shown audiences what modern anime production can achieve when a studio is given adequate time and resources. One Punch Man deserves that same level of commitment.
Madhouse: The Original Powerhouse
Let us start with the obvious answer. Madhouse animated Season 1 and it is still widely considered one of the best single-season anime ever produced. The studio’s work on the Boros fight alone set a standard that few anime have matched since. However, Madhouse has a packed schedule in 2026 with multiple ongoing projects, and bringing them back for Season 4 would require a major scheduling miracle.
MAPPA: The New Gold Standard
MAPPA has been on an absolute tear. From Jujutsu Kaisen to Chainsaw Man, the studio has consistently delivered animation that breaks social media every time a new episode drops. Their recent 15th anniversary announcement in June 2026 teased major reveals coming on June 19, and fans are already speculating that One Punch Man could be one of them. MAPPA’s dynamic camera work and fluid combat choreography would be a perfect fit for Saitama’s deadpan destruction.
Ufotable: Visual Perfection Guaranteed
If there is one studio that understands how to make anime look like a blockbuster movie, it is Ufotable. Their work on Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle proved they can handle massive-scale battles while keeping character emotion front and center. Imagine Saitama’s Serious Punch rendered with Ufotable’s signature lighting and particle effects. It would be breathtaking.
Bones: The Veteran Contender
Bones has a legendary track record with action anime. From My Hero Academia to Mob Psycho 100, the studio knows how to adapt ONE’s work specifically. In fact, Mob Psycho 100 is also created by ONE and Bones handled it with exceptional care, delivering three seasons of consistently excellent animation. They understand ONE’s storytelling style better than almost anyone else in the industry.
Wit Studio: The Dark Horse Pick
Wit Studio has been making serious moves lately. Their work on Spy x Family alongside CloverWorks proved they can handle both action and comedy, which is exactly what One Punch Man needs. The studio also recently announced their Netflix One Piece remake for 2027, showing they are willing to take on massive franchise responsibilities. A partnership with Wit Studio for Season 4 would bring fresh energy and a proven track record.
Other Studios Worth Considering
Several other studios deserve mention. CloverWorks has been producing consistently high-quality work and could bring a unique visual style to Hero Association arcs. A-1 Pictures handled Fate/strange Fake with impressive results and has the technical capacity for large-scale fight scenes. Even Studio Trigger, known for their wild stylistic choices in Kill la Kill and Promare, could bring an unexpectedly fitting energy to Saitama’s over-the-top world.
Then there is David Production, which quietly delivered excellent action sequences in JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure, and Sunrise, which remains one of the most technically capable studios in Japan despite shifting focus to mecha in recent years.
What J.C. Staff Needs to Prove
The conversation should not just be about replacing J.C. Staff. If the studio is given another chance, they need to show they can deliver consistently across an entire season, not just in select episodes. Season 3 had moments of brilliance, but fans want a full run of episodes that match the quality of Madhouse’s original season.
The decision ultimately comes down to production committee priorities. Are they willing to invest in top-tier animation to match the growing global demand, or will they prioritize budget and schedule over visual quality?
Read More on Wibux
What Do You Think?
This is where we want to hear from you. Should J.C. Staff get another shot at One Punch Man Season 4, or is it time for a studio change? Would you rather see Madhouse return for a triumphant comeback, or are you rooting for MAPPA, Ufotable, or Bones to take the reins? Drop your thoughts in the comments and let the debate rage on. The Hero Association is watching.
